Einde inhoudsopgave
The One-Tier Board (IVOR nr. 85) 2012/3.3
3.3 Many formal Acts, informal codes in US by private initiative
Mr. W.J.L. Calkoen, datum 16-02-2012
- Datum
16-02-2012
- Auteur
Mr. W.J.L. Calkoen
- JCDI
JCDI:ADS601849:1
- Vakgebied(en)
Ondernemingsrecht (V)
Voetnoten
Voetnoten
These federal securities laws were preceded by State Blue Sky laws, which were introduced in many states at the start of the 20
Conference Board (2009), p. 15 and see Eisenhofer and Barry (2010), pp. 2-38. As long ago as the 1990s former SEC commissioner and corporate law professor Roberta S. Karmel wished to issue federal corporate governance roles, but could not do so due to the Business Roundtable v. SEC decision of 1990 of the D.C. Circuit Court of Appeal (declaring a SEC rule against 'dual-class companies' void). She had already argued in favour of independent directors in 1984.
In the UK by Listing Rule 9.8.6(5) and (6) and in the Netherlands by article 2:391, 5 DCC.
Pinto and Branson (2009), pp. 3-4.
Teachers Insurance Annuity Association-College Retirement Equities Fund (TIAA-CREF), a huge pension fund and an activist shareholder and has been successful since 1992 with private communication with listed companies that brought change in corporate governance, see Willard T. Carleton, James M. Nelson and Michael S. Weisbach, 'The Influence of Institutions of Corporate Governance through Private Negotiations, Evidence from TIAA CREFF', The Journal of Finance, Vol. L111, No. 4, August 1998, pp. 1335-1361.
Risk Metrics, now called Institutional Shareholders Services, is very influential. For example, in the chapter on employee compensation in his 2009 general report to clients, well-known corporate lawyer Martin Lipton (pp. 201-206) repeatedly advises them not to ignore the recommendations of Risk Metrics.
Section 303A, sub-section 9, of the NYSE Listed Company Manual.
The sources of corporate law are the corporate law statutes of each state. Each state also has jurisprudence or common law applicable to corporations. The courts not only interpret the statutes but also create important legal practices and principles such as derivative suits and the business judgment rule. The corporate law of the State of Delaware is paramount.
Federal securities law is another important source of law for corporations. The most important federal statutes are the SEC Securities Act 1933 for "going public" and the SEC Securities Trading Act 1934 for "being public", with many other SEC regulations, which give rights for botte criminal and civil actions.1 Traditionally, the Federal Congress and the SEC have lelt corporate law to the states. The most recent statutes of importance to our subject are the SarbanesOxley Act of 2002 and the Dodd-Frank Act of 2010, with which Congress introduced some new federal corporate law by creating obligations for boards. In these cases, Congress has expanded the historical boundaries of securities law and moved closer to a federal regime for corporate governance.2
Whereas many countries, including the UK and the Netherlands, have national corporate governance codes such as the Cadbury and the Tabaksblat Codes, which have a basis in the law in that companies are obliged to explain in their accounts if they do not comply with the Code, the US has a vast number of corporate governance codes published by private groups, all of which put pressure on corporations to improve corporate governance, but have no basis in the law.3
The main semi-private organizations that have drafted codes are:
institutions: the American Law Institute (ALI), the American Bar Association (ABA) with the Model Business Corporation Act, the Conference Board, the Business Roundtable (for CE05), NACD (for directors), the Blue Ribbon Chairman's Forum, Kennesaw University, the Millstein Institute at Yale and the Kom/Ferry surveys;4
shareholder groups: Breeden for MCI, the Council for Institutional Investors, Ca1PERS,5 TIAA-CREF,6 Risk Metrics (now ISS);7
companies such as GM in 1992 and by 2004 companies like Pfizer, Intel, Frederic W. Cook & Co, Inc., some 96% of all listed companies had written guidelines on corporate governance. Establishing such interaal guidelines has been mandatory for all US companies listed on the NYSE since 23 November 2005.8